Why did the Braves pull Ian Anderson? Rookie gets through five hitless against Astros before exiting World Series

Ian Anderson has been one of baseball’s hardest pitchers to hit in his past two postseasons, and the Braves rookie was in peak form Friday night.

In Game 3 of the World Series, he was back at it against the Astros as he didn’t allow a hit over five innings. He walked three and struck out four.

But the no-hit bid wasn’t enough to keep him in the game. Braves manager Brian Snitker lifted him for left-hander A.J. Minter to start the top of the sixth, placing the no-no in the hands of his trusted relievers.

Don Larsen’s perfect game in 1956 remains the only hitless complete game in World Series history.

MORE: Braves vs. Astros live score, updates, highlights

“Obviously, you want the chance to compete and especially on the biggest stage like this is, but I knew he wasn’t going to budge,” Anderson said after the game. “You’ve got guys like [Tyler] Matzek and Minter and Luke [Jackson] and Will [Smith] at the backend coming in. You can’t blame him for going to those guys. Those guys time in and time out get it done and they did it again tonight.”

Why was Anderson pulled if he was pitching so well? Sporting News takes a look.

Pitch count

Anderson might have been dealing, but with 76 pitches at the time of his exit, it was clear he was not going to finish the game. And while the rookie had allowed no hits, he wasn’t exactly filling up the strike zone as 37 of those 76 pitches were taken for a ball.

This isn’t the first time Anderson has been lifted early in the 2021 postseason. In Game 3 of the NLDS against the Brewers, he was taken out after throwing 84 pitches in five scoreless innings. After that, he lasted three innings and 55 pitches against the Dodgers in Game 2 of the NLCS and 66 pitches in four innings against Los Angeles in Game 6.

MORE: Why Joc Pederson wears a pearl necklace during Braves games

Anderson’s outings have not lacked success. In seven career postseason appearances, he owns a 1.47 ERA, including a 2.25 mark in his three starts this year. But the Braves have a lot of faith in their bullpen, particularly Minter and fellow southpaw Tyler Matzek, to deliver key innings late.

Batting order

Had it been the bottom of the order coming up to face Anderson in the sixth, he might have been able to stay in the game. But it was not. It was the top of the Astros’ vaunted lineup, and it would be seeing him for the third time.

Facing Jose Altuve, Michael Brantley and Alex Bregman would be a tall task for any pitcher. While Altuve has been cold, he homered in Game 2 and is a consistently dangerous hitter. Brantley has scorched the ball in the World Series to the tune of a 1.000 OPS. Bregman is waiting for his first hit this postseason, but he had a .777 OPS in the regular season.

Braves manager Brian Snitker said after the game that he felt Anderson had thrown a lot of pitches to the top of the order and that he didn’t want Anderson to have to go through them again.

“I thought the fourth inning, he really had to work to get through that. He had a really good fifth inning. And then I told him, because he was like, ‘Are you sure? You sure?’ But I was like, ‘Ian, I’m going with my gut here.’ And just my eyes, my gut. It’d have been real easy to let him go out,” Snitker said. “It could’ve backfired I guess, but I just thought at that point in time, in this game of this magnitude and all that he had done his job. And we had a bullpen that all the guys we used had two days off, and they were only going to pitch an inning a piece.”

Then there are the numbers associated with Anderson facing a lineup for the third time. In 2021, batters posted a .772 OPS against him the first time through the order, .520 the second time and .764 the third time.

MORE: Mark Lemke’s 1991 World Series remains the best example of how October baseball is joyously unpredictable

And the Astros have found plenty of success facing pitchers for the third time. 

According to Stathead, the Astros posted a collective .812 OPS in the regular season when facing pitchers for the third time in a game. Altuve was stellar as he posted an .856 OPS, while Bregman had a .738 mark and Brantley posted a .690 OPS, per Stathead.